Tweets, status updates, blogs: we spend a lot of time voicing our message, communicating our opinions, talking to (at?) others about what we believe in - a right old case of meme warfare.
Not so much time is spent on listening.
For sure, we do listen, sometimes, but even then it’s only to some people; only to the people that we side with, our own choice victims. For feminists, women; for race activists, ethnic minorities; for capitalists, businesses; for Marxists, workers; for recovering addicts, current drug-takers; for labour voters, the vulnerable in need of public services; for conservatives, the employed who need lower taxes.
My friends, there is something painful in that, this myopia, that we only listen to the suffering we identify with – to everyone else, we preach, pontificate, even persecute, determined to being them ‘on side’, to our side. Sure, why wouldn’t they support our cause, worthy as it is? Except they’re supporting their own cause, as worthy also, as that actually is.
This is a very sad situation. A very stuck situation.
Camps of tribal affiliations, groups of equally noble causes fighting their own corner, fighting each other. I’ve often seen this: that something isn’t good enough, because it doesn’t include everything else. Conservatives are wrong, pulling back spending on public services in their pursuit of lower taxes for the employed, because they don’t speak enough about protecting the vulnerable. Labour is wrong, seeking to maintain spending on public services for the vulnerable, seeking to invest more capital in infrastructure to build houses, because they don’t speak enough about the need to reduce the deficit, to relieve the burden of debt on the next generation. A polarity thus develops, both sides declining to see the full picture: that we are no longer as well off as a society, that perhaps taxes have to either remain constant or even go up if we wish to maintain the current level of social services, and at the same time, in the face of these higher taxes, we must nevertheless accept a reduced quality of life. There simple isn’t as much to go around. Mother Earth hasn’t got as much left to give.
Nowhere is this tribalism more evident than on Twitter, where camps of different tribes, affiliated to their own chosen values and causes, form exclusive cells with impermeable membranes.
For me, I’d much rather belong to no group. Whenever I feel myself getting subsumed into one camp or another I subvert the process by focusing on something else. I abhor affiliations - political, ideological, religious, whatever. I like to promote a diverse, sometimes conflicting array of narratives: feminism, equality, Buddhism, social welfare, the NHS, mental health, environmentalism, renewable energy, population controls, atheism, banning pornography, reformed/regulated capitalism, a non-regulated press, and nuclear decommissioning. I buy the Observer and The Telegraph on Sundays. Both usually make good points.
But that’s just me.
My point is that life is too complex, too complicated to foster simplistic affiliations. That’s far too close to religion, to dogma, for me. I’m a complex person, with strengths and weaknesses. I make good points sometimes, and terrible mistakes. I find it hard to see both sides of the story most of the time, but I want to try, and I have a right to try. On Twitter I’ve seen people being jumped for trying to consider an alternative view, and quite often I’ve been the one doing the jumping. I don’t like this part of me – I don’t think it’s useful, let alone humane. And I don’t like the process. It smacks of the schoolyard fight where everyone gathers round chanting ‘fight, fight, fight’. There’s an absence of human dignity in it. I want to be more patient, more at ease with difference. I want to feel less of a megalomaniac, living as I sometimes do from some bizarre, arrogant belief that I can change the world if only I say the right thing at the right time to the person I believe needs to hear what I want to say.
I can’t change the world.
So, if there’s anything I want to be able to say upon my death bed, then, it’s not that I changed the world (an impossible task!), but that I made a difference to some people, and that I tried to understand, and that I was as non-violence as I could be. To do that, I need to listen more. Maybe the last thing that I can do then, on my death bed, is listen, to those around me, and to myself, to just listen and try to understand.
When all is said and done, maybe that’s the only thing left to do, to listen and try to understand.
A blog exploring diverse views and celebrating difference while also maintaining that some views may be more humane than others, not just different.
Monday, April 1, 2013
Saturday, March 30, 2013
News Round-up (March 24th-30th)
BENEFITS: Stay-at-home parents have seen tax increases since coalition came to power, unlike single- or both-parents who go to work, who have all seen reductions. Suggestions that Tories undervalue stay-at-home parents taking root.
(Telegraph)
MEDIA REGULATION: “Hands off from my interwebz!" says local blogger.
(Twitter)
HEALTH AND SAFETY: Triangular flapjacks banned for health and safety reasons, but not square or rectangular flapjacks. Many concerned about the increase of corner-related injuries.
(BBC Radio 4)
ON THE PAPERS: Telegraph and Sun move to join Financial Times and others embracing paywalls. The Guardian denies intent of doing same, despite its online advertising revenue failing to sustain newsrooms. Many now ask: How much is news worth?
(BBC Radio 4)
CELEBRITY: Angelina Jolie at Nzolo camp in DR Congo fights to raise awareness of warzone rape in Africa.
(Metro)
EDUCATION: Teachers call for children as young as eight to be taught about risks of porn, including sexting. Also in the news, teacher strikes looking likely as general discontent on the increase.
(Metro; Guardian)
NEWS ON NEWS: Various stories of isolated, heart-breaking tragedies involving ordinary people you never knew.
(Metro etc.)
BANKING: Cyprus decides not to raid Cypriot deposits under EU100,000. Bigger deposits hit by up to 100% as Cyprus attempts to remain in the Euro. Decades of hardship predicted as Cypriot economy teeters on the brink.
(Guardian)
IMMIGRATION: Tory focus on immigrants continues, as new, more stringent conditions on how immigrants access welfare and housing is proposed. Many worry of increased inequality, with the UK at odds with EU legislation on human rights. Farage of UKIP highlights the duty of government to house the homeless as undermining Cameron’s intentions. Others highlight how less than 2% of immigrants claim unemployment benefit, far below the national average.
(Guardian)
FEMINISM: Femen in the spot-light: some question their naked tactics - others emphasis freedoms and empowerment. On Twitter, @winnersusedrugs is faced with misogynistic backlash as she comes out in criticism of video-game conference “booth girls”. Those in support of her analysis called for a better view of women in the gaming industry.
(Guardian; Twitter)
POLITICS: Conservative narrative of ‘anyone can succeed if only they try hard enough’ read by some as ‘poverty is sinful’. Says Guardian journo satirically: "the state must shrink to a nub, because the humans who need it don't deserve it."
(Guardian)
WEATHER: Brits grit teeth as temps hit the pits.
(Various)
POLITICS: Mair maims mayor as Boris Johnston is stripped down by Eddie Mair in publicly celebrated interview accusing the conservative top dog as ‘a nasty piece of work’. Boris later praises Mair’s work.
(BBC)
Saturday, March 23, 2013
News Round-Up
HOUSING: Tories divided as local councillors seek to protect ‘environmental safeguards’ accusing government of ‘over-development’ while national Conservative party seeks to galvanise house-building market, injecting £3.5b into New Homes Scheme.
FEMINISM: Twitter inflamed over#Steubenville as sympathy expressed for convicted rapists, including on CNN, and suggestions repeatedly made that rape victim was partly to blame.
INTERNATIONAL NEWS: Cyprus in chaos as politicians desperately seek solution to crippled banking system – a 25% bank levy on savings deposits over EU100,000 currently proposed. Observers fear bank run and immanent collapse. Banks have been closed for last seven days.
WEATHER: Bristol struck by cold snap, while nation’s eye turns to dwindling gas reserves as supply from Belgium is cut off by pump failure.
POLITICS: Labour pull ahead in polls as Conservative stick to current economic policy (Poll Average: Con: 30 Lab: 40 Lib-Dem: 11)
MEDIA: Newspapers contemplate new cross-party agreement on new regulations backed by law. Early indications suggest some may refuse to sign. Supporters insist regulations protect freedom of the press while protecting the public.
RELIGION: New pope calls for a ‘poor church’.
WELFARE: “Bedroom Tax” to be implemented as “Mansion Tax” is dropped – nation split between the need for housing and the needs of the vulnerable. Conservatives reward both parents when they decide to work by offering more childcare support – many now ask how much Tories value the work of stay-at-home parents.
FEMINISM: Twitter inflamed over
INTERNATIONAL NEWS: Cyprus in chaos as politicians desperately seek solution to crippled banking system – a 25% bank levy on savings deposits over EU100,000 currently proposed. Observers fear bank run and immanent collapse. Banks have been closed for last seven days.
WEATHER: Bristol struck by cold snap, while nation’s eye turns to dwindling gas reserves as supply from Belgium is cut off by pump failure.
POLITICS: Labour pull ahead in polls as Conservative stick to current economic policy (Poll Average: Con: 30 Lab: 40 Lib-Dem: 11)
MEDIA: Newspapers contemplate new cross-party agreement on new regulations backed by law. Early indications suggest some may refuse to sign. Supporters insist regulations protect freedom of the press while protecting the public.
RELIGION: New pope calls for a ‘poor church’.
WELFARE: “Bedroom Tax” to be implemented as “Mansion Tax” is dropped – nation split between the need for housing and the needs of the vulnerable. Conservatives reward both parents when they decide to work by offering more childcare support – many now ask how much Tories value the work of stay-at-home parents.
Sunday, February 17, 2013
Authority's End
Pluto is in Capricorn, and authorities are being relentlessly cross-examined: the police, the government, MPs, Celebrities, the Church, the media, the BBC, the NHS. It is a time of great upheaval, both in the stars, and on the ground. I don’t believe in astrology, but certainly the stars are not far off on this particular subplot of the zeitgeist.
What does it mean, then, to be without authority? More specifically, to be without an external authority? Classically, we’ve killed our fathers, possessed our mothers. Patriarchy is eating itself.
We’ve got nothing to guide us, only appetite, desire, the need for an endless, directionless “more”.
Here, in the great silence of a murdered God, in the graveyard of moral certitude, there resides a trembling silence, a open plot.
We stand alone in ourselves, our own hearts and minds our only guide. Do we have the confidence, the groundedness, the courage to follow our own lights? What does our own voice sound like, apart from the multitude of voices we try to discern around us and try to please on a daily basis? What do we, in ourselves, think is right, beyond what gets us praise or blame? Who are we, apart from what we think we are perceived to be by Others?
The child stands with dagger in hand and Daddy dead. The child looks about, realising what it has done. What next? For Mommy cannot be possessed forever. She will die, her nurture end. All that remains now is the inevitability of being left, alone. What then for the child without authority, without guidance, with nothing but its own heart and mind to heed? What then?
To pluck the fruit of adulthood from this wasteland of destruction – is it possible? Is it inevitable? Is it even conceivable?
What does it mean, then, to be without authority? More specifically, to be without an external authority? Classically, we’ve killed our fathers, possessed our mothers. Patriarchy is eating itself.
We’ve got nothing to guide us, only appetite, desire, the need for an endless, directionless “more”.
Here, in the great silence of a murdered God, in the graveyard of moral certitude, there resides a trembling silence, a open plot.
We stand alone in ourselves, our own hearts and minds our only guide. Do we have the confidence, the groundedness, the courage to follow our own lights? What does our own voice sound like, apart from the multitude of voices we try to discern around us and try to please on a daily basis? What do we, in ourselves, think is right, beyond what gets us praise or blame? Who are we, apart from what we think we are perceived to be by Others?
The child stands with dagger in hand and Daddy dead. The child looks about, realising what it has done. What next? For Mommy cannot be possessed forever. She will die, her nurture end. All that remains now is the inevitability of being left, alone. What then for the child without authority, without guidance, with nothing but its own heart and mind to heed? What then?
To pluck the fruit of adulthood from this wasteland of destruction – is it possible? Is it inevitable? Is it even conceivable?
Friday, January 18, 2013
A turn for the different.
These days I’ve taken to be, well, less political and more creative – something that happens to me annually; winter stokes the coals of my birthing-burner like an old man poking at the open fire, sending up crackling sparks that from out of the dark set his peering, crinkled face aglow. I scratch the flint over these faceless stones, and from that comes strange tales, mystic messages. Warmed, I shimmy up to these building flames, listen to the roar in the hearth, and let myself dream.
The cold, sharp clink of metal brought down on metal – clink.
These days there is a controlled violence in my words, an accuracy that is visceral. I look forward to these moments with the muse, like one might look forward to an evening’s chat with a close friend before the fire. Nodding and smiling, turning over thoughts between two: ploughing the field.
These days I relish such moments, where I treat words with the respect they are due, select them, and place them, with care. With care, yes. This is the season when I create with care.
The cold, sharp clink of metal brought down on metal – clink.
These days there is a controlled violence in my words, an accuracy that is visceral. I look forward to these moments with the muse, like one might look forward to an evening’s chat with a close friend before the fire. Nodding and smiling, turning over thoughts between two: ploughing the field.
These days I relish such moments, where I treat words with the respect they are due, select them, and place them, with care. With care, yes. This is the season when I create with care.
Wednesday, June 27, 2012
A Step too Far? What's the Story with Social Welfare?
Everything has a price tag these days, from politicians' expenses to the Olympics' opening ceremony. In any one day, on reading The Guardian alone, we are informed how much Barclay's has been fined (£290m) and how much in bonuses Bob Diamond will now forego as a result of the Barclay's shambles (£2.7m). We also know how much fuel duty Brits will no longer have to pay (3p), as George Osborne does a U-turn, and we're told how much this will cost the government (£550m). We are informed that London bus drivers are striking over Olympic bonuses, and told how much exactly these bonuses are (£500). The list goes on, from the cost of loan companies to how much the M&S Chief Executive is being paid; even how much BT Vision paid for 114 Premier League football matches (£738m).
Never before have people known so well the price of everything. When the cake gets smaller, we all start eyeing the crumbs.
No wonder then, that the welfare system is now being scrutinised under the analytical, economic eye of the public. And yet, how we look at the costs of the welfare system, and what story we pin these costs to, makes a great deal of difference in the world of politics.
Take, for example, the last few months and years, where a story has been slowly building around the welfare state, about how much it costs the UK and whether those who benefit from it actually deserve such benefits. A provocative story, no doubt; yet stories, however moving, can be very misleading. Compare, for example, the story that 'the government will pay out more in social security benefits than it raises from workers in income tax this year (2009)' to the story that 'the UK is ranked significantly below many other European nations in terms of how much it spends on welfare, including France, Germany, and Italy'.
Of course, we've been inundated with figures, the latest eye-watering figure to join this deluge of price tags being how much housing benefit for the under 25s costs the UK every year - coming in at £2bn. Add that to the total UK debt: £1tr (up £2.7bn in a year)
The analogy that's made, then, is of course the image of a family in debt. You can't borrow your way out of debt, you've got to cut back, right? Of course! And to do that, you've got to spend less, right? Duh!!
So, that's what the government is doing. Cutting back to pay off their debts, and the place they've chosen to do this is social welfare; the reason being that there are too many people dependant on the state. Social welfare gives the wrong impression, that you're better off on benefits than working for a living. This from Cameron:
'A couple will say, "We are engaged, we are both living with our parents, we are trying to save before we get married and have children and be good parents. But how does it make us feel, Mr Cameron, when we see someone who goes ahead, has the child, gets the council home, gets the help that isn't available to us?"One is trapped in a welfare system that discourages them from working, the other is doing the right thing and getting no help.'
It's a provocative, and somehow alluring argument. It does indeed sound incredibly unfair!
In the face of the economic facts and figures, Cameron has focused on cutting back the welfare state in order to help pay off the UK's debts. Dependency on welfare, described here as the "welfare trap," needs to be tackled, and urgently. Cameron is not alone. The Telegraph, along with a great many middle-class couples living at home, not to mention a great many Tory donors, clearly supports the PM's agenda. Here, the story of a whole generation raised on a 'culture of entitlement,' looms large. A very alluring argument: blame it on the feckless young. Just look at them, listening to their terrible music and causing nothing but trouble!
But, let's take a step back for a minute. There is another way to tell this story.
In the hours and days immediately following the news that Cameron was setting his sights on removing housing benefit for the under 25s, a whole swathe of dissenting voices rang out, not least of which was Polly Toynbee's, who described Cameron as "stirring up those on quite low incomes against those on very low incomes". Here, writes Toynbee, Cameron is deliberately setting up a false dichotomy, dividing and ruling, by 'pitting "those who work hard and do the right thing" against those on benefits, all the time ignoring the fact that these are for the most part the very same people'. Polly confronts us with a whole new set of figures that Cameron has chosen to overlook:
For a start, the majority of people claiming benefits are not unemployed at all, they are the low-paid employed, the workers and cleaners, care-assistants and child-care workers, the people who clean our streets and who take care of our elderly loved ones, the people who mind our children. They are the 62% living below the poverty line who are employed but require benefits to survive. And as a counter-narrative for those who mean to suggest that this is a tidal wave of scroungers, 95% of the rise in housing benefits this year is paid to people in work. Only one in eight people who rely on housing benefit are out of work.
So, what the hell is going on then? What kind of story can we tell, if the problem of rapidly rising welfare costs can't be explained away solely by scapegoating a minority? How inconvenient, that we have to think a little harder.
Well, Owen Jones of The Independent, along with Polly Toynbee, attempts to explain the situation, not by blaming the inner psychological workings of the so-called undeserving poor, but by examining three external factors that feed in to this rapidly snowballing situation: low wages, high housing costs, and a dearth of job opportunities.
Regarding low wages, The Living Wage Foundation currently sets the living wage at £7.20/hr. With the national minimum wage set at £6.08 for those over 21 and £4.98 for those 18-20, we can see there's a bit of a deficit between what many are being paid on minimum wage and what is needed to survive in the UK. As such, people are relying on benefits to top-up their wages, not to scrounge. So, in this instance, taxes aren't primarily going to scroungers living off social welfare, they're subsidising big businesses who refuse to pay a living wage. Combine this with the rising cost of living and you might be tempted to think that it's not so much about cutting benefits, but increasing wages.
How about that for a twist in the tale?
The story doesn't end there, however. 95% of the increase in housing benefit is being paid to people in work who can no longer afford to pay their rent because their wages do not cover the costs. Housing costs have been rising far more than the minimum wage, and far more than the rate of inflation, three times more, to be exact. Again, then, instead of singling out a minority, and describing their apparent immoral inner workings, the temptation now might be to focus on reducing rents in the private sector, by, for example, imposing a cap on how much private landlords can charge, or maybe reducing the cost of buying a house, by investing in more social housing. After all, it's not so much that taxes are going towards maintaining feckless teenagers in the lap of luxury; they're going into the pockets of rich landlords who raise rents beyond affordability. Capping rents would mean all those people who are working on minimum wage might be able to afford their rents, or even get a mortgage, without having to rely on benefits in order to survive.
And finally, the elephant in the room, which doesn't require much more of my word count: How can you fit 2.5m unemployed people into 460,000 job vacancies?
In all this it's interesting to note that it is the so-called free-loading chav, the scrounger, who is the one deemed immoral, and not the big businesses who refuse to pay a living wage, or the private landlords who raise rents to impossible heights. Just as Jimmy Carr was scapegoated for the failure of the government to impose a fairer, more water-tight tax system, here too, the unemployed are singled out instead of the wider malaise, a system run by capitalist values, that is so out of control the government needs to subsidise it in order for it to survive, by paying housing benefit to the already employed, for example, not to mention bailing out banks.
Add to all this the final fact that we all intuitively know, that:
As each year passes, and the richest one per cent get richer still, the rest of the best-off ten per cent increasingly have a little more in common with the remaining nine-tenths of society, and less and less in common with those at the very top.The only people gaining from all this are the richest of the rich, who have seen extraordinary rises in their wealth over the last few years.
[T]here has been a short, sharp entrenchment of inequality in the past two years. Last year, the earnings of FTSE 100 executives went up by 49%, while the annual pay of waiters and waitresses fell by 11% and those of cleaning staff by 3.4%. The average director at Britain's top 100 companies now earns 145 times more than their average worker.We might note too, that a quarter of these people, the richest of the rich, are Tory donors.
So, now that we know the price of everything, which story do we want to tell?
Has the welfare state taken a step too far, encouraged a generation of entitled scroungers? Are we angry that our taxes are supporting this undeserving free-loader? On the other hand, has capitalism gone too far? Are we not angry that our taxes are subsidising big businesses who won't pay a living wage, and rich landlords who raise rents to unaffordable levels? Is David Cameron taking a step too far, by drawing back the welfare state in the wrong way at the wrong time, when to do so will only leave a rising number of people unable to cope? Is that the way we wish to end the tale? With rising homelessness, increased poverty, and a widening gap between the richest and the rest? Or do we want to create a different ending, by looking at establishing a living wage and investing in social housing, creating jobs, and laying the foundation of a good future for the next generation? Wouldn't that be a nice ending?
So, now that we have the figures, what's the story with social welfare? More to the point: which story do we want to tell?
Something Terrible
To see something terrible happening to a human being, click *here*.
Friday, June 22, 2012
A Funny Scapegoat: Jimmy Carr
This week the UK media decided to make Jimmy Carr the next victim of public condemnation, and our Mr. Cameron, PM, took it upon himself to add fuel to the flames by commenting directly upon Mr. Carr's nefarious financial affairs:
I think some of these schemes – and I think particularly of the Jimmy Carr scheme – I have had time to read about and I just think this is completely wrong.
People work hard, they pay their taxes, they save up to go to one of his shows. They buy the tickets. He is taking the money from those tickets and he, as far as I can see, is putting all of that into some very dodgy tax avoiding schemes.
That is wrong. There is nothing wrong with people planning their tax affairs to invest in their pension and plan for their retirement – that sort of tax management is fine. But some of these schemes we have seen are quite frankly morally wrong.
The government is acting by looking at a general anti-avoidance law but we do need to make progress on this. It is not fair on hardworking people who do the right thing and pay their taxes to see these sorts of scams taking place.
As is often the case these days, I came across the breaking news of Jimmy's "morally repugnant behaviour" on Twitter. As is also often the case, I found myself embroiled in a heated argument about it with a fellow twitterer, @tsdlee. This charming young man, arrested by the power of my intellectual prowess, has since blocked me. He was convinced that Jimmy was "greedy" and "morally wrong". He asserted that Jimmy should not be avoiding tax, especially if he earns more than £3m a year. Also, if he was intent on avoiding tax, he should at least give some of his many millions to charity. At the time, I found myself thouroughly infuriated by the man's magnanimous moralising.
On reflection, I can of course see Lee's point, but at the time I found Lee to be "judgemental, sanctimonious, hypocritical, and presumptuous," to quote myself. On asking Lee how much he gave to charity, he was reticient. It was 'as much as he could when he could'. I presumed this was, well, not often.
I asked Lee if he knew how much Jimmy gave to charity, and Lee replied:
I'm pretty sure he doesn't give 44% of his income to charity. I've never heard him give anything to charity.
I directed Lee to the following, found after a cursory Google search 'Jimmy Carr charity'. Jimmy clearly does give to charity, and probably a lot more than Lee.
I was getting angry now, because I felt Lee was simply using Jimmy Carr as a way to perpetuate Lee's favourite story, that rich people are evil, greedy sods who don't give to charity. (A story I too like to proliferate, on occasion, I must admit). Lee did all this even though he knew almost nothing about Carr, who he was using to perpetuate his story. That's when, obviously in following the link I had given him, Lee replied:
Ah good. Glad he's donating to charity and is getting relief on the 1% tax he actually does pay. Smart man.
I lost it, and posted:
You're a twat. He's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't.
Lee, in my mind, had simply refused to change his story. Nothing was going to work. I was convinced this guy was the reason for all the ills of the world.
This personal exchange between Lee and I, and the event Jimmy found himself in, are not unrelated. Let me explain the connection I have in mind by going back to Jimmy for a moment:
Having found himself in the midst of a Cameron-induced twitterstorm, inflamed by the anonymous, yet somehow personal accusations of disgust flung in Carr's direction like detritus by a hoard of foaming tweeters, Mr. Carr had quickly offered up a public apology, removed himself from the noxious implications of this now infamous K2 scheme, and ducked his head below the media radar in the hope that, for the love of God, this tidal wave of public scorn would pass as quickly as it came. Lee, perhaps exasperated by my attempt to beat him down with my retorts, blocked me. Society had done to Jimmy what I had found myself doing to Lee. In the midst of a system we all know to be based on greed and inequality, we had focused our attention on arbitrary individuals, and let loose.
Yes, that term is called scapegoating. Scapegoating is all too common in our society today. Like when the Tories say the UK economic crisis is the result of Labour 'leaving the country in a mess,' while Labour, with equal venom, say that the country's mess is a result of the Conservative's austerity agenda. Both are wrong, because, quite likely, both are right. They are wrong because they assume that whatever is the cause, someone else is to blame. What's certain, they believe, is that they are not responsible. After all, to even hint at taking responsibility in this society would lose a political party hundreds of thousands of votes. Taking responsibility as a politician is a sign of weakness, certainly political suicide. As a result, in this world, everyone's a victim, because everyone else is to blame.
The process of blame is no more apparent than when we scapegoat, but there is another element in scapegoating. We single out a target. It might be one political party, or one individual. They come to symbolise the problem that ails us. They become the cause of the sickness. Yes, they're the reason I'm in this mess. He's the reason me and my family are struggling. We overestimate the power one party or one person can have; a natural consequence of the culture of individualism in western society today. And so all our anger gets directed towards a solitary focal point, some poor bastard that never saw it coming. Like Jimmy Carr, or Lee, who suddenly find themselves overwhelmed by the irascible anger of people convinced that they are the reason the whole damn world has gone to pot.
So scapegoating is a natural consequence of the poison of extreme individualism mixing with the equally toxic venom of the blame culture we find ourselves living in today. It's as if we look around and see that all the fish in the pond are poisoned, but instead of trying to clean the pond, we single out an individual fish as the cause for the ills of all the rest. We then isolate this fish, ostractise it, and demand it somehow change, become well. If it doesn't it shall pay by being excluded, derided, rejected by the school. We don't notice that we, the accusers, and them, the accused, all swim and drink the same toxic water in equal quantities.
In sum, we direct our anger at individuals or groups, not contexts or systems. Maybe because it's easier, and feels more visceral. Maybe because we're so familiar with the context that it becomes invisible. We can see a single fish, with sickly scales and cloudy eyes. We can pick him out. We can't see the murky water. It's everywhere, far more unidentifiable.
This is apparent in how we, inspired by Cameron, singled out Jimmy Carr. It's also apparent in how I singled out Lee. I didn't see Lee as one sick fish amongst many, all of us swimming in a poisoned pond. I saw him as a source of this poison. He wasn't swimming in judgemental waters, he was judgemental. He wasn't swimming in the poison of hate and resentment. He was being hateful and resentful. In doing this, I myself was falling prey to the poison's effects.
In a sense Lee is of course a source of this poison: he transmits poisonous toxins via public forums into others, so that the pond becomes ever more saturated with toxic meaning. A vicious cycle becomes locked in, self-perpetuating: others agree, and retweet. A tidal wave of indignation ensues. I fell into that cycle and became a part of it too, scapegoating Lee just as much as Lee scapegoated Jimmy.
In another way, however, Lee isn't the source of this poison. Lee is actually being force-fed this toxic story about heroes and villains by the media and powerful people who have access to this story-telling machine, in this case Cameron, who sends his favourite stories out into the system as poison into our pond, to be learned by rote by the rest of us, like a song you hear so often you just can't get it out of your head. Just look around: Twitter-feeds and Facebook news-feeds are dominated by stories told by the powerful, through the mass media. There are countless other stories not being told, because no-one powerful enough who has access to the media wants to tell them. You have to trawl twitter to find these alternative tales, these counter-cultural narratives.
The stories we are flooded with day by day are written by the powerful people in our society, people with their own, often political agendas. Lee, in a sense, had no choice but to get swept away by Cameron's tale. The same narrative was everywhere. On every online newspaper website. Every tweet with #JimmyCarr on it. He drank up this poison, poured out with such apparent non-chalance by newsgroups, Cameron, and tweeters, that, Yes! Jimmy was the villain we were looking for!
There's a pay-off in all this too, a reward in scapegoating, and this is a feeling of belonging. Lee found himself admitted into a large group of irate anonymous tweeters who were expressing similar views and feelings to him. For sure, I too felt a sense of pleasure when other tweeters seemed to agree with me against Lee, that Carr was not the problem but that the system in which he lived was to blame, a system that legalised, endorsed, and sold him the K2 scheme. I felt vilified, part of a larger group, when I saw they agreed with me. I felt right, not merely because I felt right in myself, but because others agreed with me. As such, I didn't just feel right, I felt righteous.
This is another poison that can motivate us to do terrible things: group think. The school of fish swims this way and that, so that we, mere individual fish, follow blindly, making sure we avoid becoming isolated, wishing to remain hidden in the crowd. It's interesting that scapegoating is the opposite to this desire to blend in, as it singles out and isolates an individual from the rest of us. So, even if the school is actually moving deeper into the most toxic parts of the pond, we'll follow, because we fear standing out. We don't even think about it. We merely follow. Even when we become more ill, we continue to follow. An example of such obedience, even when faced with having to perform evil acts, is no more evident than in Milgram's Experiment (obedience) and the Stanford Prison Experiment (group think).
In our case the poison is scapegoating, and it's poisonous because it violently singles out one man as if he's the cause of all our anger, when actually the problem is far bigger. To scapegoat only harms one man, potentially deeply, but it changes absolutely nothing. It's like witch-hunting because there's a plague killing your family. It's poisonous to us too, this scapegoating, because we think we're achieving something when we're not. We're simply wasting energy on the wrong thing. We get angry and stressed out at this scapegoat, yet remain totally ineffectual in the grand scheme of things. The system remains intact. And yet, we get swept away by the crowd again and again. We get irate along with the rest. The toxins seep into our system. We remain sick.
So, what can we do about this? What's the alternative? What's the antidote?
Well, despite all our confidence that we were right, the problem is, we were all wrong: the tweeters who were against Jimmy, saying he was evil and greedy, and the tweeters who were defending Jimmy, saying he was merely doing what we would all do. Both sides we're wrong. But we weren't wrong because of what we were asserting. Our assertions were right. Jimmy was being greedy. But he was also only doing what we in the same position would do. Both sides were wrong because both sides were convinced the other side was wrong. Both sides were convinced that the other side was the poison. But this is patently wrong, because every one was right.
All must have prizes.
Part of the solution, then, is to stop isolating, or threatening to isolate individuals or groups, through scapegoating, and start looking at the system instead - ways we can all live together that don't involve poisoning the pond. For example, why does Jimmy get £1.5 million a year to tell jokes, when a nurse who saves lives and puts up with all manner of drunks and abuse on weekends, only gets £25,000? Is it because Jimmy is greedy and evil? No, Jimmy is taking what he's being offered, by society. Clearly, we as a society value entertainment more than we value carers; just look a footballers' salaries compared to mental health workers. Society, the pond, is sick with rotten values.
What Jimmy did was totally legal. What Jimmy did was very, very greedy. Jimmy, however, just like us, is swimming in this poisoned pond, our western society. This society is fuelled by the values of 'individualism,' 'capitalism,' and 'the need for more'. It values entertainment over care, popularity over character, growth over ecology, profit over ethical values. So, when his accountant suggested a way for him to save tax, Jimmy probably didn't look at the details. He just went along with it - it's legal right, so why not? Capitalism dictates that we have a right to make as much money as possible, as long as you remain within the law. Capitalism is not about thinking of others. Neither is individualism, where the only one person looking out for you, is you. So, you've got to take care of number one. It wasn't even that Jimmy "disregarded his responsibility to pay his fair share" - quite likely he didn't think about his responsibility at all. And why would he? Our society is not built on such values. Instead we have capitalism and competition - our society is based on capitalising on others, seeing them as commodities even, not helping them.
And as for responsibility, it is interesting to note how those who blame are equally guilty of neglecting their responsibility: Cameron and Lee walk on very shaky ground when it comes to the responsibilities they expected of Carr. Cameron's family was built on tax avoidance, for example. Lee only "gives when he can," which probably isn't often. Yet Cameron is morally repulsed, and Lee expects Carr to be charitable. And, again, wouldn't we all snap up the opportunity to pay only 1% tax on our income if given the chance, because more money in our pockets is, well, 'more'? And that's got to be good, hasn't it?
This is all very telling, because it suggests we are all poisoned, but that we only see the sickness in others.
So, perhaps we ought to reserve judgement of individuals and direct our attention towards changing the system. For example, the Robin Hood Tax scheme proposes putting a minor tax on financial transactions that could put billions into the public purse every year. 2020 Tax proposes simplifying the tax system so that tax avoidance becomes almost impossible. I'm not saying these proposals are perfect, I'm just saying they focus on changing the system, not scapegoating individuals, and that they may be a step in the right direction. It's interesting, though, that these two proposals remain significantly overlooked by a mass media which spends all its time scapegoating celebs, politicians and CEOs. Maybe because it's more entertaining for us to read the drama of a celeb being ripped to shreds. More entertaining than Richard Murphy, perhaps, who proposes other ways to reform, if not outright revolutionise, the UK tax system. Here is where real change can happen, not least of which through the narrowing of the gap between rich and poor. The question remains, though, if we as a society are ready to take things seriously? Or whether we are too intoxicated by the poison in the pond, so that we'd rather tear strips out celebs and CEOs than look at how we can change the system for the better, while all the time the pond continues to grow evermore saturated by the toxins that poison our bodies and cloud-up our minds.
Finally then, we need to stop singling out individuals. We need to see and change the bigger picture. Only then, with cleaner water and altered currents, will individuals begin to grow healthy and swim a different course. Only in this way can we hope to embrace the possibility of cleaning the poisoned pond.
Labels:
Cameron,
greed,
Jimmy Carr,
K2,
scapegoat,
tax avoidance,
twitter
Wednesday, June 13, 2012
Not Happy with your Lot? That's Rich.
I'm confused.
I've been having one of those self-flagellating mornings where I don't get on and do what I should be doing (studying for my exams), but rather immerse myself in the popular motifs of my society, the Zeitgeist, if you will, of the modern, western psyche.
It has not been an inspiring morning.
It all started with the interweb, as it usually does. More precisely, it started with two Yahoo articles. These articles, given their topics and their location on the web, provide me, I believe, with a fairly accurate sample of the average person in the UK today. Unfortunately, what this sample seems to suggest is that we are a bunch of ungrateful, thoroughly spoilt brats.
The first article I came across was a journo-tisement about RBS and NatWest. Today, they are unveiling a new piece of technology that allows people to use smart-phones to take out cash from ATMs. Not the most ground-breaking of news, but nothing that should inspire any great degree of malcontent either, right?
Well, wrong. As is their wont, along comes a rusty-hinge of moaners, with a plethora of complaints, ranging from how this will just be an other way for thieves to run off with our money, that this new technology won't catch on, that they should improve phone signals (which are terrible) first, that smart-phones are overpriced and pointless anyway, that phones should be for calls and texts only, that you'd need a forklift to take out your cash from an ATM these days...
The whinging went on and on and on.
Out of the first 18 comments, only one directly acknowledged that this technology might be a positive thing. The rest for the most part were critical and even paranoid. I moved on.
The second article asked: is it worth working? It compared the income of those on minimum wage with those on the median wage and went on to deduct the costs of working (including taxes, transport, and so on) from the gross median salary. This essentially reduces an hourly rate of £13.46 to £8.11, which is close to the hourly rate of minimum wage, which is £6.08. The suggestion was, why work if essentially your only getting £2.00 above minimum wage. Excuse me, sir, but is this the motif you were looking for?
Of course, there are massive holes in the article, such as factoring in that those on minimum wage also have travel expenses, and so on, so that their rate reduces too and the gap between minimum and median wage widens again. And then there's the idea that, if you don't have a job, you can expect that hourly rate (when you are on benefits) to be far, far lower. But, that is not our main concern here.
As with the first article, it was the comments that struck me the most, with outbursts such as:
And again:
As a society, we've been spoilt rotten. We've been given everything, which has somehow led to us feeling as if we've got nothing. I mean, for someone living in the UK, employed or not, they will in almost all cases, have a home, running water, hot water, electricity, food, warmth, shelter from the rain, easily accessible food stores, public transport, a free, easily accessible healthcare system, freedom of speech, freedom of movement, an environment relatively free from the ravages of war and/or civil unrest, racism or ethnic cleansing... the list goes on! And yet, we focus on what we feel we've been deprived of, on what more we want but don't yet have. A big part of the problem, then, is that our wanting is out of control.
This is all part of the sickness of society, part of what I talked about a few days back. This is the poisoned pond, a place in which we all live and become intoxicated. Part of the poisoning is losing the capacity for gratitude, for recognising what we've got. We become ungrateful and entitled, and in the process, lose our capacity to feel any kind of happiness or contentment. In this way the cycle continues, as we repeatedly convince ourselves that we are being deprived, that we are "slaves" somehow, when perhaps we are merely slaves to our own, out-of-control desires and our inability to feel satisfied.
Part of the process of healing then, is remembering what we do have, and in the process, acknowledging that actually, if we have electricity, a laptop, free healthcare and so on, then we've got a lot more than most. Keeping a gratitude journal, a place to write down what we are grateful for, is a helpful antidote to the poison in the pond. For example, let's not forget that if you receive the minimum wage in Britain, you are still in the top 7% in terms of global wealth, and that already factors in the cost of living. Indeed, part of the healing process is changing the story, from one of deprivation and entitlement, to one of gratitude and responsibility. In short, this is about no longer acting like a spoilt child. In short, this about growing up.
[Click the links in the text above for more information.]
I've been having one of those self-flagellating mornings where I don't get on and do what I should be doing (studying for my exams), but rather immerse myself in the popular motifs of my society, the Zeitgeist, if you will, of the modern, western psyche.
It has not been an inspiring morning.
It all started with the interweb, as it usually does. More precisely, it started with two Yahoo articles. These articles, given their topics and their location on the web, provide me, I believe, with a fairly accurate sample of the average person in the UK today. Unfortunately, what this sample seems to suggest is that we are a bunch of ungrateful, thoroughly spoilt brats.
The first article I came across was a journo-tisement about RBS and NatWest. Today, they are unveiling a new piece of technology that allows people to use smart-phones to take out cash from ATMs. Not the most ground-breaking of news, but nothing that should inspire any great degree of malcontent either, right?
Well, wrong. As is their wont, along comes a rusty-hinge of moaners, with a plethora of complaints, ranging from how this will just be an other way for thieves to run off with our money, that this new technology won't catch on, that they should improve phone signals (which are terrible) first, that smart-phones are overpriced and pointless anyway, that phones should be for calls and texts only, that you'd need a forklift to take out your cash from an ATM these days...
The whinging went on and on and on.
Out of the first 18 comments, only one directly acknowledged that this technology might be a positive thing. The rest for the most part were critical and even paranoid. I moved on.
The second article asked: is it worth working? It compared the income of those on minimum wage with those on the median wage and went on to deduct the costs of working (including taxes, transport, and so on) from the gross median salary. This essentially reduces an hourly rate of £13.46 to £8.11, which is close to the hourly rate of minimum wage, which is £6.08. The suggestion was, why work if essentially your only getting £2.00 above minimum wage. Excuse me, sir, but is this the motif you were looking for?
Of course, there are massive holes in the article, such as factoring in that those on minimum wage also have travel expenses, and so on, so that their rate reduces too and the gap between minimum and median wage widens again. And then there's the idea that, if you don't have a job, you can expect that hourly rate (when you are on benefits) to be far, far lower. But, that is not our main concern here.
As with the first article, it was the comments that struck me the most, with outbursts such as:
"for sure it is not worthy going to work if you salary is close to minimum wage. MODERN DAY SLAVERY!!!!!- dont forget slavery has been on since the creation of societies."
And:- Fran, London
"Factor in the interest paid to the bankers on your mortgage etc and you soon come to the conclusion that you are, always have been and always will be a slave, nothing more nothing less. A slave. Now go back to sleep and dream of winning the lottery you pathetic bunch of losers."
- A Yahoo User, Huddersfield
And again:
"Slave labour is back and thriving"
The slavery theme came up repeatedly. I couldn't help replying:- Martin, London
To ya'll who are saying this is modern day slavery, have you lost your minds?
Because having a TV, microwave, laptop, hot water, drinking water, food around the corner, a home to live in, public transport, free healthcare, and so on is soooooo similar to being chained to a line of people with no house, no clothes, no freedom, no identity, no healthcare, or similar even to a person with no home, no food, no water, no healthcare, no future.
Yeah, because we are slaves of privilege, slaves of entitlement, slaves of ingratitude. We have no idea what we've got. We [are] all convinced [that] we are so deprived.
And that's it really, in a nutshell. At least, for me it is.- Me
As a society, we've been spoilt rotten. We've been given everything, which has somehow led to us feeling as if we've got nothing. I mean, for someone living in the UK, employed or not, they will in almost all cases, have a home, running water, hot water, electricity, food, warmth, shelter from the rain, easily accessible food stores, public transport, a free, easily accessible healthcare system, freedom of speech, freedom of movement, an environment relatively free from the ravages of war and/or civil unrest, racism or ethnic cleansing... the list goes on! And yet, we focus on what we feel we've been deprived of, on what more we want but don't yet have. A big part of the problem, then, is that our wanting is out of control.
This is all part of the sickness of society, part of what I talked about a few days back. This is the poisoned pond, a place in which we all live and become intoxicated. Part of the poisoning is losing the capacity for gratitude, for recognising what we've got. We become ungrateful and entitled, and in the process, lose our capacity to feel any kind of happiness or contentment. In this way the cycle continues, as we repeatedly convince ourselves that we are being deprived, that we are "slaves" somehow, when perhaps we are merely slaves to our own, out-of-control desires and our inability to feel satisfied.
Part of the process of healing then, is remembering what we do have, and in the process, acknowledging that actually, if we have electricity, a laptop, free healthcare and so on, then we've got a lot more than most. Keeping a gratitude journal, a place to write down what we are grateful for, is a helpful antidote to the poison in the pond. For example, let's not forget that if you receive the minimum wage in Britain, you are still in the top 7% in terms of global wealth, and that already factors in the cost of living. Indeed, part of the healing process is changing the story, from one of deprivation and entitlement, to one of gratitude and responsibility. In short, this is about no longer acting like a spoilt child. In short, this about growing up.
[Click the links in the text above for more information.]
Saturday, June 9, 2012
The Toxic Pond
I've got my feet up on a make-shift chaise lounge here in Clifton, Bristol, listening to Leftfield as the cappuccino goes stale on my tongue. Bacon and eggs, sausages and tomatoes, churn in my bloated belly. An aura of satisfaction melds with the dappled golden light that plays on the carpet. I smile, Saturday morning middle-class contentment suffusing my being.
If only this satisfaction could be enjoyed in full - enjoyed, that is, without this slight but unmistakable element of dis-ease.
You see, nothing much has changed:
The room I reside in is in a house from the Victorian era. The basements of houses from around this time often housed the servants, where they used to work and live beneath the aristocratic upper class on the floors above. The world of the privileged was built on top of the world of the less privileged, the "under-class". Much luxury, and much leisure time, was only possible through the efforts of those who worked far harder, had less luxury, and less leisure time (a maid could work from 6am to midnight).
To be sure, it wasn't effort that earned you this freedom from toil. It was a birth right, a privilege handed down through the generations.
Nothing much has changed.
Just as it was difficult to move between these classes, back in the day, today it is likewise expected that you stay in the class you were born into, especially if you were born in the US or UK. Likewise today, the upper class's privileges are built on the backs of those below, except today "the class below" is not just the working classes, but also the generation behind, our children.
It seems self-evident really:
In a society of limited resources, the privileges I have today are only possible by depriving others of these same things. Not everyone can have exactly what I have (above minimum wage salary, a nice place to rent, a job), or more than this (a car, and house to buy, regular holidays abroad), because there isn't enough of this stuff for everyone. What I have today has not been earned, though it is very easy to imagine that it has. Actually, what I have has been granted to me by virtue of being born into a class of society - the middle-class. Had my mother not been middle-class, and had my third level education not been free, I would not be writing the way I am now. I would not speak as I do. I would not get the jobs I can get now. I would be decidedly less well off.
In short, it is those on minimum wage, and also, those to come, the next generation, who are being faced with the burden of this, our unsustainable extravagance, our credit-fuelled intoxication, our middle-class privileges. We need to face up to that, and take responsibility.
Our wealth was an illusion, credit-based, and now we are trying to maintain the illusion by making others pay. Now, faced with the prospect of withdrawal, we attempt to shift the burden of our lifestyles onto the most vulnerable people today, and tomorrow, by dismantling, piece by piece, the welfare state, and by unravelling free-education and creating massive student debts. We even try to make the old pay, by siphoning money out of pensions. So, we attempt to live on top of those with less than us. In the very same way as the even richer, the people on the second and third floors, attempt to live on top of us, the middle-class, so they can live a life of even more privilege.
We are not better than the stinking rich, who strive to siphon money away from us and into their own pockets through the banks, for we likewise attempt to ease the burden of the debts we owe by forcing those who do not have as much as us to have even less. For example, we are in the process of guaranteeing that our children will have less than us by dismantling free-education.
Not a very palatable analysis of our humble middle-class lives. Not an easy pill to swallow. Not the treatment you were looking for, that would help you rest in peace.
A wise man once said:
As such, these words of mine are not designed to sooth. As I said, my movement towards a middle-class contentment is tainted, interrupted. But interrupted by what exactly? Having too much? No. Having too little? No. It is interrupted by having more than, for no other reason but because I was born into a certain class, a certain neighbourhood, a certain set of privileges.
That which my conscience cannot adjust to, that which disturbs me, is the unequal distribution of wealth in society. And I'm not the only one to feel uneasy.
The UK and the US not only have some of the poorest rates of social mobility, making it difficult to move beyond the class you were born into, but also, the the US and UK have some of the highest levels of wealth inequality. This is the profound sickness, the toxic pond if you will, in which we as fish both swim and breathe.
This is the reason why I feel dis-ease. This is the reason why the young and the less well off take to the streets. Such protesting and rioting are merely symptoms of the disease of inequality, the only cure for which is a more equal distribution of wealth. Until then, we all, rich and poor, must resign ourselves to swimming in poisoned water, and therefore, we must resign ourselves to feeling ill at ease, to feeling the dis-ease that is inherent in the make-up of our society.
Some Evidence:
A TED Talk on social mobility and the consequence of an unequal distribution of wealth in society:
http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/en/richard_wilkinson.html
Stats on social mobility across developed countries:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility#Country_comparison
If only this satisfaction could be enjoyed in full - enjoyed, that is, without this slight but unmistakable element of dis-ease.
***
You see, nothing much has changed:
The room I reside in is in a house from the Victorian era. The basements of houses from around this time often housed the servants, where they used to work and live beneath the aristocratic upper class on the floors above. The world of the privileged was built on top of the world of the less privileged, the "under-class". Much luxury, and much leisure time, was only possible through the efforts of those who worked far harder, had less luxury, and less leisure time (a maid could work from 6am to midnight).
To be sure, it wasn't effort that earned you this freedom from toil. It was a birth right, a privilege handed down through the generations.
Nothing much has changed.
Just as it was difficult to move between these classes, back in the day, today it is likewise expected that you stay in the class you were born into, especially if you were born in the US or UK. Likewise today, the upper class's privileges are built on the backs of those below, except today "the class below" is not just the working classes, but also the generation behind, our children.
It seems self-evident really:
In a society of limited resources, the privileges I have today are only possible by depriving others of these same things. Not everyone can have exactly what I have (above minimum wage salary, a nice place to rent, a job), or more than this (a car, and house to buy, regular holidays abroad), because there isn't enough of this stuff for everyone. What I have today has not been earned, though it is very easy to imagine that it has. Actually, what I have has been granted to me by virtue of being born into a class of society - the middle-class. Had my mother not been middle-class, and had my third level education not been free, I would not be writing the way I am now. I would not speak as I do. I would not get the jobs I can get now. I would be decidedly less well off.
In short, it is those on minimum wage, and also, those to come, the next generation, who are being faced with the burden of this, our unsustainable extravagance, our credit-fuelled intoxication, our middle-class privileges. We need to face up to that, and take responsibility.
Our wealth was an illusion, credit-based, and now we are trying to maintain the illusion by making others pay. Now, faced with the prospect of withdrawal, we attempt to shift the burden of our lifestyles onto the most vulnerable people today, and tomorrow, by dismantling, piece by piece, the welfare state, and by unravelling free-education and creating massive student debts. We even try to make the old pay, by siphoning money out of pensions. So, we attempt to live on top of those with less than us. In the very same way as the even richer, the people on the second and third floors, attempt to live on top of us, the middle-class, so they can live a life of even more privilege.
We are not better than the stinking rich, who strive to siphon money away from us and into their own pockets through the banks, for we likewise attempt to ease the burden of the debts we owe by forcing those who do not have as much as us to have even less. For example, we are in the process of guaranteeing that our children will have less than us by dismantling free-education.
***
Not a very palatable analysis of our humble middle-class lives. Not an easy pill to swallow. Not the treatment you were looking for, that would help you rest in peace.
A wise man once said:
"It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society"
As such, these words of mine are not designed to sooth. As I said, my movement towards a middle-class contentment is tainted, interrupted. But interrupted by what exactly? Having too much? No. Having too little? No. It is interrupted by having more than, for no other reason but because I was born into a certain class, a certain neighbourhood, a certain set of privileges.
That which my conscience cannot adjust to, that which disturbs me, is the unequal distribution of wealth in society. And I'm not the only one to feel uneasy.
The UK and the US not only have some of the poorest rates of social mobility, making it difficult to move beyond the class you were born into, but also, the the US and UK have some of the highest levels of wealth inequality. This is the profound sickness, the toxic pond if you will, in which we as fish both swim and breathe.
This is the reason why I feel dis-ease. This is the reason why the young and the less well off take to the streets. Such protesting and rioting are merely symptoms of the disease of inequality, the only cure for which is a more equal distribution of wealth. Until then, we all, rich and poor, must resign ourselves to swimming in poisoned water, and therefore, we must resign ourselves to feeling ill at ease, to feeling the dis-ease that is inherent in the make-up of our society.
Some Evidence:
A TED Talk on social mobility and the consequence of an unequal distribution of wealth in society:
http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/en/richard_wilkinson.html
Stats on social mobility across developed countries:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility#Country_comparison
Hunger
Revolution is a consequence of hunger. Without hunger, there is no need for revolution.
What then, of the current generation of youths? How hungry do you think
they're going to get, when they're unemployed for one, two, three, five
years?
How recognisable do you think they'll be, when you see
them take to the streets, no longer looking for recognition or justice,
but now demanding atonement? How afraid
are you, you people in your 30s, 40s, and 50s, that a whole wave of
youths are living with empty bellies and clenching fists? How aware are
you, that they look upon you with hate? How aware are you of their
reasons why? That you have left them with no jobs, a mountain of
historical debt, a raped and dying ecology; that you take no
responsibility for the destruction you have wrought, while they live
with the legacy of your carelessness.
Hunger... hunger is the
essential ingredient of revolution. You are not hungry, perhaps, in your
job, with a comfortable apartment or house, with your free education
and your secured futures, with your unsustainable pensions that take the
money from your own child's future pockets, giving them a bill instead.
They are hungry... they are angry... and they blame you.
Saturday, November 19, 2011
The Age of Rage: An Occupied Response.
On November 10th, 2010, angry student protesters stormed the
headquarter of the Conservative Party, 30 Millbank, in violent clashes
with the police. This August saw London, Manchester, and other cities in the UK swept
by rioting and looting, and yet more violent clashes with the police. Now, in the last few months, flash-points of conflict between
protesters and the police as the occupy movement declines to be silenced by the governments of various
countries, states and provinces. But, it's not just the students, the
looters, or the occupy protesters that are angry, nor even just the
police in their often brutal responses. Onlookers are angry
too.
Some of these onlookers rain venom on the bankers and politicians: an outrage that we have to bail out the banks, they say. Others are vitriolic in their criticisms of the looters: feral youths engaging in wanton criminality - lock them up, they say. And still more scoff and spit at the protesters: these smelly scroungers need to get a job and stop living off the state, or, if they have a job, they should just shut the fuck up and work like the rest of us. Many private sector workers with pensions are furious with public sector workers for striking to save their pension schemes: we pay for your pensions but can't afford our own - you need to take a hit like the rest of us and stop holding the country to ransom, they say. Public sector workers fume in return: yeah, let's just compare how much more you get for doing the same job I do - then we'll talk about what's fair.
When the cake gets smaller, we're all reduced to fighting over the crumbs.
Well, not all of us, just the majority of us. A few have all the cake they can dream of.
And the majority of us are, then, angry; but more than this, we are angry at each other. We don't just get angry at those who have far more cake than we'll ever see, we get angry at each other. We want more crumbs than the other guy.
So, what to do?
We'll the Buddhist would say reduce your desires, so that you have less need to be angry about the things you haven't got. And try to be grateful for what you have got. Indeed, statistics show that violent unrest and a sense of entitlement are not related to poverty per se but perceived highly unequal distribution of wealth. We are particularly enraged when we perceive a clear gap between what I have and what others have. So, the Buddhist would say stop wanting. That way you won't be angry when you see how much others have compared to you. You'll just be happy with what you've got.
Now, that's all fine and well if you're a monk in a monastery, and you know you'll have fellow monks to take care of you when you're old. Or if you're in your 20s, with a part-time job, with mommy and daddy to fall back on if times get hard. But, what if you're a single man or woman in his 30s or 40s who's thinking, what happens to me when I'm 70 and can't work anymore? I can't afford a private pension on my current salary. I don't have kids who'll take care of me. I can't even afford to buy a house! I can only afford to get from week to week. What then? This isn't just about having desires, this is about feeling safe and secure in our old age, and having the hope that we can move forward. And none of us can thrive, emotionally or socially, without a basic degree of security regarding food and shelter. Thing is, many of us are suddenly realising that despite being in full-time jobs, such basic levels of security are clearly lacking. Even the idea that those who are 20 or 30 now we'll get a basic state pension when they retire is uncertain.
Not surpising then: we're afraid. And yet, we've done what we were told was required of us. We've kept within the law, we've worked hard, we've done our part. And yet, our basic needs might not be met when we are vulnerable. That makes people angry. Scared, and very, very angry. After all, resentment is one of the most powerful motivators. As is fear.
So, having less desires is not the antidote to this collective rage. So, what then?
Well, the occupy movement, on the back of revolutionary new ways to communicate such as twitter and mobile phones, has become something of a network of "anger hubs", where individual rage can collate, build, network, learn, collectivise and empower itself. Basically, the occupy movement sends the message out to all those who are angry: you have a right to be angry - indeed, if you're not angry, you're either not paying attention, or you one of the few, super rich benefactors of the current capitalist model, the notorious "1%". The occupy movement validates anger.
And indeed, the occupy movement has attracted many people from widely diverse backgrounds: the homeless, public sector workers, small business owners, students, social workers, counsellors, the unemployed, the disabled, lawyers, nurses, and many more. All are angry. But, and perhaps not unsurprisingly given the above, the occupy movement has attracted lots of angry criticism too. They're a blight on the city, aesthetically unpleasing to the eye. They're wasters without jobs who should stop indulging their sense of entitlement, and just get a job. They're professional protesters, who have nothing better to do than spark trouble. Or they're not real protesters, because they go home at night and get up for work the next day. Most recently, they're just smelly hippies who need a bath. Beneath all this criticisms, we inevitably sense anger.
We're angry, because we're forced to fight over crumbs.
What the occupy movement suggests, however, is that we shouldn't have to fight over crumbs. The fact is there is plenty for everyone, it's just the case that the few have far more than the rest of us, who in turn don't have enough to feel secure. And that is what makes for the anger we're seeing, not just on the side of the occupiers, but even those who angrily criticise the occupiers. The primal emotion is not anger, perhaps. Perhaps it's fear: I don't have enough, so you better shut the fuck up asking for more, because it might just come out of my pocket. No wonder many then are happy to see police brutality exacted on people fighting for their future. If they don't get more, I'm more likely to keep getting the crumbs I get.
And that is what makes me angry. I'm angry because it simply doesn't have to be this way. There are multi-billionaires who'll tell you that anyone can be a billionaire, but that's just bullshit, put there to make you feel that it's your fault for not having enough money, even if you're a single mom who struggles to afford child-care if she wants to get an entry level job and work her way up - she's stuck; even if you're a student who comes out of college with £35,000 of debts to pay off and finds he can only get a job in Tescos, stacking shelves for free, with no guarantee of a job at the end. That makes me angry, and rightly so. Money is being siphoned away from the majority of us who are struggling to get by, the 99%, only to line the pockets of those who already have far more than they, or even their kids, will ever need. And at the heart of it, a banking system designed to make money less valuable and products more expensive so it can cash in on interest when people get credit to buy the things they need to survive securely.
It's not right. And in a system that is not just, there is bound to be anger. This anger will surface in many ways: looting, protesting, striking, even trolling. They're all manifestations of resentment, and a deeper fear that there's not enough to go around. But there is enough to go around, it's just that the few have far, far more than the rest of us can even imagine.
The occupy movement makes it clear, then, that until that gap in wealth is reduced, there can be no peace in this, or any other country.
Some of these onlookers rain venom on the bankers and politicians: an outrage that we have to bail out the banks, they say. Others are vitriolic in their criticisms of the looters: feral youths engaging in wanton criminality - lock them up, they say. And still more scoff and spit at the protesters: these smelly scroungers need to get a job and stop living off the state, or, if they have a job, they should just shut the fuck up and work like the rest of us. Many private sector workers with pensions are furious with public sector workers for striking to save their pension schemes: we pay for your pensions but can't afford our own - you need to take a hit like the rest of us and stop holding the country to ransom, they say. Public sector workers fume in return: yeah, let's just compare how much more you get for doing the same job I do - then we'll talk about what's fair.
When the cake gets smaller, we're all reduced to fighting over the crumbs.
Well, not all of us, just the majority of us. A few have all the cake they can dream of.
And the majority of us are, then, angry; but more than this, we are angry at each other. We don't just get angry at those who have far more cake than we'll ever see, we get angry at each other. We want more crumbs than the other guy.
So, what to do?
We'll the Buddhist would say reduce your desires, so that you have less need to be angry about the things you haven't got. And try to be grateful for what you have got. Indeed, statistics show that violent unrest and a sense of entitlement are not related to poverty per se but perceived highly unequal distribution of wealth. We are particularly enraged when we perceive a clear gap between what I have and what others have. So, the Buddhist would say stop wanting. That way you won't be angry when you see how much others have compared to you. You'll just be happy with what you've got.
Now, that's all fine and well if you're a monk in a monastery, and you know you'll have fellow monks to take care of you when you're old. Or if you're in your 20s, with a part-time job, with mommy and daddy to fall back on if times get hard. But, what if you're a single man or woman in his 30s or 40s who's thinking, what happens to me when I'm 70 and can't work anymore? I can't afford a private pension on my current salary. I don't have kids who'll take care of me. I can't even afford to buy a house! I can only afford to get from week to week. What then? This isn't just about having desires, this is about feeling safe and secure in our old age, and having the hope that we can move forward. And none of us can thrive, emotionally or socially, without a basic degree of security regarding food and shelter. Thing is, many of us are suddenly realising that despite being in full-time jobs, such basic levels of security are clearly lacking. Even the idea that those who are 20 or 30 now we'll get a basic state pension when they retire is uncertain.
Not surpising then: we're afraid. And yet, we've done what we were told was required of us. We've kept within the law, we've worked hard, we've done our part. And yet, our basic needs might not be met when we are vulnerable. That makes people angry. Scared, and very, very angry. After all, resentment is one of the most powerful motivators. As is fear.
So, having less desires is not the antidote to this collective rage. So, what then?
Well, the occupy movement, on the back of revolutionary new ways to communicate such as twitter and mobile phones, has become something of a network of "anger hubs", where individual rage can collate, build, network, learn, collectivise and empower itself. Basically, the occupy movement sends the message out to all those who are angry: you have a right to be angry - indeed, if you're not angry, you're either not paying attention, or you one of the few, super rich benefactors of the current capitalist model, the notorious "1%". The occupy movement validates anger.
And indeed, the occupy movement has attracted many people from widely diverse backgrounds: the homeless, public sector workers, small business owners, students, social workers, counsellors, the unemployed, the disabled, lawyers, nurses, and many more. All are angry. But, and perhaps not unsurprisingly given the above, the occupy movement has attracted lots of angry criticism too. They're a blight on the city, aesthetically unpleasing to the eye. They're wasters without jobs who should stop indulging their sense of entitlement, and just get a job. They're professional protesters, who have nothing better to do than spark trouble. Or they're not real protesters, because they go home at night and get up for work the next day. Most recently, they're just smelly hippies who need a bath. Beneath all this criticisms, we inevitably sense anger.
We're angry, because we're forced to fight over crumbs.
What the occupy movement suggests, however, is that we shouldn't have to fight over crumbs. The fact is there is plenty for everyone, it's just the case that the few have far more than the rest of us, who in turn don't have enough to feel secure. And that is what makes for the anger we're seeing, not just on the side of the occupiers, but even those who angrily criticise the occupiers. The primal emotion is not anger, perhaps. Perhaps it's fear: I don't have enough, so you better shut the fuck up asking for more, because it might just come out of my pocket. No wonder many then are happy to see police brutality exacted on people fighting for their future. If they don't get more, I'm more likely to keep getting the crumbs I get.
And that is what makes me angry. I'm angry because it simply doesn't have to be this way. There are multi-billionaires who'll tell you that anyone can be a billionaire, but that's just bullshit, put there to make you feel that it's your fault for not having enough money, even if you're a single mom who struggles to afford child-care if she wants to get an entry level job and work her way up - she's stuck; even if you're a student who comes out of college with £35,000 of debts to pay off and finds he can only get a job in Tescos, stacking shelves for free, with no guarantee of a job at the end. That makes me angry, and rightly so. Money is being siphoned away from the majority of us who are struggling to get by, the 99%, only to line the pockets of those who already have far more than they, or even their kids, will ever need. And at the heart of it, a banking system designed to make money less valuable and products more expensive so it can cash in on interest when people get credit to buy the things they need to survive securely.
It's not right. And in a system that is not just, there is bound to be anger. This anger will surface in many ways: looting, protesting, striking, even trolling. They're all manifestations of resentment, and a deeper fear that there's not enough to go around. But there is enough to go around, it's just that the few have far, far more than the rest of us can even imagine.
The occupy movement makes it clear, then, that until that gap in wealth is reduced, there can be no peace in this, or any other country.
Friday, November 18, 2011
Is a Capitalist Reformation Possible?
In the last two years we've had corporate tax evasion; we've had expenses scandals; we've had students become the next generation of designated debt-bearers as universities embrace business models, tripling fees; we've had the threat of the privatisation of the NHS; we've had the banking crisis, where tax payers bail out banks that print money and keep it in their own vaults, crippling growth; we've had massive cuts across the public sector in order to prop up a flailing financial market, thrashing in the history of its own excesses; but, more important than all this, we've had a movement determined to repeatedly highlight all these disturbing truths, to connect them and emphasise them, to make meaning from them. Thanks in large part to the occupy movement capitalism is currently under the spotlight, surgically pinned in stark vivisection.
The question arises, then, as we gawp at capitalism close up, its guts on show for all to see: can such an organism provide for society in general, or is it by nature designed to provide for the few, by robbing the many?
Clearly, capitalism has become something monstrous, destructive, but for some, it hasn't always been this way.
For some, like Richard Branson, capitalism used to be benevolent:
Richard Branson believes that it is possible for capitalism to once again work for the people, but can we believe such a statement? Has capitalism lost our trust? Can capitalism reform itself? If it can, how? And if it can't, what then? Are there even any other viable options? Have we created a monster that now seeks to destroy society? Have we lost control? Or can we rein in this beast, domesticate it, so that it serves all of us, and not just the few?
The occupy movement, it seems to me, is quite understandably split on this issue. Some are angry that the movement has been repeatedly addressed as an "anti-capitalist movement" when in fact no such consensus has been reached; many seek to merely regulate capitalism, as opposed to seeking its total dismantlement. What it's total dismantlement would look like, as a working model, remains to be adequately detailed. For sure, the occupy movement is experiencing its own dialectic on this issue. For others to expect unity here is not only unrealistic, it's unhelpful. The question needs to be explored thoroughly.
The question "can capitalism be reformed?" is an incredibly important question, because if the answer is yes, then perhaps we could start from there and seek to regulate, or better still, convince businesses to freely, willingly think beyond mere profit. If Richard Branson is being genuine and not just indulging the "ethical" market, like the Co-Operative Bank has done, then perhaps there is hope for capitalism. Perhaps it can find its soul; but that remains to be seen. And if the answer is no, if it becomes apparent that capitalism cannot be reformed, what then? Can it be dismantled? Can it be replaced? And if so, replaced by what, and by what means? Government policy? Revolution?
These questions and more are what now fills the minds of the many, as we collectively peer into the pulsing innards of this beast called capitalism, lying splayed in vivisection upon the operating table. Standing around this creature, studying it, we are faced with the question: what kind of animal is capitalism? Can it be tamed, and if not, can it be terminated?
The question arises, then, as we gawp at capitalism close up, its guts on show for all to see: can such an organism provide for society in general, or is it by nature designed to provide for the few, by robbing the many?
Clearly, capitalism has become something monstrous, destructive, but for some, it hasn't always been this way.
For some, like Richard Branson, capitalism used to be benevolent:
"I truly believe that capitalism was created to help people live better lives, but sadly over the years it has lost its way a bit. The short-term focus on profit has driven most businesses to forget about the important long-term role they have in taking care of people and the planet."
Richard Branson believes that it is possible for capitalism to once again work for the people, but can we believe such a statement? Has capitalism lost our trust? Can capitalism reform itself? If it can, how? And if it can't, what then? Are there even any other viable options? Have we created a monster that now seeks to destroy society? Have we lost control? Or can we rein in this beast, domesticate it, so that it serves all of us, and not just the few?
The occupy movement, it seems to me, is quite understandably split on this issue. Some are angry that the movement has been repeatedly addressed as an "anti-capitalist movement" when in fact no such consensus has been reached; many seek to merely regulate capitalism, as opposed to seeking its total dismantlement. What it's total dismantlement would look like, as a working model, remains to be adequately detailed. For sure, the occupy movement is experiencing its own dialectic on this issue. For others to expect unity here is not only unrealistic, it's unhelpful. The question needs to be explored thoroughly.
The question "can capitalism be reformed?" is an incredibly important question, because if the answer is yes, then perhaps we could start from there and seek to regulate, or better still, convince businesses to freely, willingly think beyond mere profit. If Richard Branson is being genuine and not just indulging the "ethical" market, like the Co-Operative Bank has done, then perhaps there is hope for capitalism. Perhaps it can find its soul; but that remains to be seen. And if the answer is no, if it becomes apparent that capitalism cannot be reformed, what then? Can it be dismantled? Can it be replaced? And if so, replaced by what, and by what means? Government policy? Revolution?
These questions and more are what now fills the minds of the many, as we collectively peer into the pulsing innards of this beast called capitalism, lying splayed in vivisection upon the operating table. Standing around this creature, studying it, we are faced with the question: what kind of animal is capitalism? Can it be tamed, and if not, can it be terminated?
Sunday, November 6, 2011
Metaphor for use by the Occupy Movement
It doesn't have to be a race to the bottom:
Imagine a multi-story building. On each floor there's the same amount of people, but as you get higher in the building each floor has more food, and it's better quality. So, for example, people on the 20th floor have plenty of food, they never run out, and it's pretty good quality. On the top floor, you've got highly luxurious food, and they've so much they're throwing buckets of it away everyday.
Now, on the 5th floor, there's not really enough food, so everyone is kind of fighting for their share, and even then, it's pretty crap quality. People below the 5th are pretty much hungry all the time. Get the picture?
Now, imagine you found yourself on the 4th floor. Of course, you want to be, you know, up there.
But, here's the thing. Instead of saying, 'Hey, why don't people on the top floor share all the food they don't need?' or even 'Hey, the people on the top floor have way more than us!' many people actually say 'That guy on the 5th floor is struggling, but hell, he's got more than me." They say this because if they work in the private sector the other guy has a state pension! Or, if they work in the public sector, they other guy gets paid more for doing the same job. So, on both sides, they say about they other guy (or gal) 'He should be down here with me, with the rest of us on the 4th floor.'
Is that smart?
I don't think so; because the folks on the top floor see all this in-fighting and laugh at such divisiveness. And they stoke the petty resentments, they fuel the division between public and private sector. After all, the more in-fighting there is, the less united people are against them.
[Post Script
The Occupy Movement represents a group of people on the lower floors, united against those on or near the top floor. They're not interested in petty squabbles between groups on the lowest floors, whether it's worse, for example, to be paid less, and get a heavily cut pension, or to be paid more and have no pension at all. They want to form a united front, the 99% of people forced to struggle on scraps and credit, against the 1% who have far more than they need and control the assets you live in (homes) and on (businesses and banks).]
Imagine a multi-story building. On each floor there's the same amount of people, but as you get higher in the building each floor has more food, and it's better quality. So, for example, people on the 20th floor have plenty of food, they never run out, and it's pretty good quality. On the top floor, you've got highly luxurious food, and they've so much they're throwing buckets of it away everyday.
Now, on the 5th floor, there's not really enough food, so everyone is kind of fighting for their share, and even then, it's pretty crap quality. People below the 5th are pretty much hungry all the time. Get the picture?
Now, imagine you found yourself on the 4th floor. Of course, you want to be, you know, up there.
But, here's the thing. Instead of saying, 'Hey, why don't people on the top floor share all the food they don't need?' or even 'Hey, the people on the top floor have way more than us!' many people actually say 'That guy on the 5th floor is struggling, but hell, he's got more than me." They say this because if they work in the private sector the other guy has a state pension! Or, if they work in the public sector, they other guy gets paid more for doing the same job. So, on both sides, they say about they other guy (or gal) 'He should be down here with me, with the rest of us on the 4th floor.'
Is that smart?
I don't think so; because the folks on the top floor see all this in-fighting and laugh at such divisiveness. And they stoke the petty resentments, they fuel the division between public and private sector. After all, the more in-fighting there is, the less united people are against them.
[Post Script
The Occupy Movement represents a group of people on the lower floors, united against those on or near the top floor. They're not interested in petty squabbles between groups on the lowest floors, whether it's worse, for example, to be paid less, and get a heavily cut pension, or to be paid more and have no pension at all. They want to form a united front, the 99% of people forced to struggle on scraps and credit, against the 1% who have far more than they need and control the assets you live in (homes) and on (businesses and banks).]
Saturday, October 29, 2011
Painful Learning: Being Occupied by Feminism
Personal growth is rarely pain-free, and my current brush with the Occupy Movement in Bristol is no exception, it having seriously challenged me to look at my values and alter my approach to the issue of marginalised groups in society.
One major challenge, to be detailed in this blog entry, is realising how women are treated in society, and by me, and how men, like me, often feel as if we have a right to tell women what to do. Take my humiliating, and humbling, experience below.
Who am I to....
Last week, I stumbled upon a blog by Marina S on "Portable Safe Spaces and Occupying the Occupation" via the #OccupyBristol Twitter Feed.
The blog clearly outlined a problem: women were not feeling safe on the Occupy Bristol site. It clearly proposed one possible solution: women could form a closed group on the site, a group that would aim to maintain a certain number of women in that group at all times. In this way, the blog concluded, no single woman would be made to feel vulnerable. Simple, right?
Wrong. Along comes an arrogant, meddling, white privileged male ass (me) with a response that went something like:
Essentially, though I hadn't seen it yet, I had said:
For now, I simply felt as if I was offering constructive criticism, as no doubt other men also felt who made their own suggestions, only to find themselves met with cutting replies, replies that were venomous, scathing, enraged.
I was left shocked, stunned, baffled by these responses, not just from Marina, but others too. My replies detail this disbelief and are still available to see. They chronicle my struggle to see Marina's point of view, my struggle to understand why Marina was so upset. On top of my confusion, clouding my mind, was my ego, deeply bruised, revolting against the public scolding. I spent a sleepless night and a tense day turning over in my head what I had said, and how Marina had responded. Surely, I hadn't said anything that bad. Surely...
Thankfully, I brooded. I took a look around. I came across another blog by Marina, her SlutWalk Bristol speech, which, apart from being passionately and brilliantly written, refers to the harsh fact that there are 94,000 rapes in the UK every year. Accounting for repeat victimisation, that means 55,000 women are raped - every year. The worst thing about this figure is that a third of people will believe that the woman was somehow to blame for being raped. Surely the only person to blame for the rape is the rapist, right? Apparently not, according to popular opinion, because if she flirted she's partly to blame, or if she was too drunk, she's partly to blame. In any case, here was a reality I did not have to think about every day of my life. I was not vulnerable to being one of these 55,000 rape victims. Why? Because I am a man.
So, now I had some numbers, some facts. Uncomfortable facts. I still struggled to understand what was wrong with my comments, though. Why had I provoked Marina to reply so aggressively? What, if anything, had I done wrong? I was tempted to dismiss her as an angry feminist, but no, that was too easy. I wanted to understand.
I continued looking around, clicking through links on Marina's pages, and so on. Then, my next deeply educational moment came along, via an article I found, unapologetically titled, 'Dick Privilage'. Here, the author, Forty Shades of Grey, addresses Richard Dawkins, who attempted to downplay, indeed deny, the reality of Rebecca Watson's discomfort when she was propositioned at 4am in an empty elevator by some guy, after having given a talk on how uncomfortable it made her feel to be sexualised. Forty Shade of Grey speaks to Richard, thus:
Something clicked: it was the 'you don't get to tell her how to feel'. Marina's reply to me came to mind:
I saw, vaguely, that I was trying to have a say about something I had no personal experience of and had no real right to direct. More than that, there was something about control here. Forty Shades of Grey has quite clearly painted a picture of a woman not in control of her environment, her culture. She had no control over being seen as less-than within her society. Then, along comes me, white privileged male, who's never experienced such marginalisation, misogyny, and abuse, convinced I should have a say in what Marina's group do or do not do in order for them to feel safe.
A rather simple idea was slowly dawning on me: Women, just because they're women, feel less safe than men, because men are convinced that they have a right to dominate women, just because they are men.
And what was I doing? I was trying to tell Marina what to do. Oh, Christ, I thought, I think I get it. I was mirroring the problem, not the solution. My values, which I had assumed beneficent and relatively progressive and egalitarian, began to reveal themselves as nothing other than "privileged". Even though I wasn't telling Marina what to do because I thought she was less than, I was still trying to tell her what to do within a culture of male privilege which has for centuries dominated her as a woman, just because she is a woman. Her rage, I realised, was perfectly understandable.
Finally, it was the following analogy, contained in the comments of Forty Shades of Grey's blog:
This ended, for me, some decades long tensions I had been carrying, often emerging in angry deabtes with my feminist partner, about how I always felt insulted and outraged when women talked about men as rapists. But I'm a man, I'd say, angrily. And I'm not a rapist. I don't want to be seen as a rapist! But, now I was thinking: And? What's your point, John? Some men are rapists, clearly. And quite a few actually, if 55,000 women get raped every year. Women don't know which man is the rapist, and which man is not. It's not for you, John, like Dawkins, to go about demanding women not feel scared of you, or uncomfortable, because you're not a rapist. They do feel scared, uncomfortable, unsafe, because some men are rapists.
It was all falling into place.
I was seeing differently, but I was also behaving differently: Walking across the road, I noticed a women walking along the path I was about to join. It was dark. Previously, I wouldn't have thought anything about it, and, as she was a little ahead of me, I would have ended up walking behind her, only to feel annoyed by the thought 'maybe she feels scared by me walking behind her' because I don't want to be seen as a rapist. This time, however, I simply accepted that she might feel uncomfortable if I ended up walking behind her on a dark street with not many people around. So, I sped up a bit and joined the path walking in front of her. End of problem. Simple. Afterall, which is more important, my desire to not be seen as a potential rapist, or her fear that I might be just that, a rapist?
Naturally, I hesitated a while before openly apologising to Marina on her blog - blasted pride! - but I found myself arguing against other men who were making comments similar to my original remark: telling Marina how she and her group should be on the Occupy Bristol site.
All of this, of course, was a very humbling experience. I still feel rather uncomfortable about it. As a counsellor, Health Care Assistant and Support Worker, I had hoped to be more aware and sensitive to the experiences of the marginalised, having worked with the sexually, emotionally and physically abused, people seen as having "mental health issues," and people with learning difficulties. All these people are to some extent excluded or marginalised by society. I had even called myself a feminist! But, I had discovered just how much my privilege had blinded me to their experience.
I feel very grateful for Marina's replies to my initial stupidity, in that their venom catapulted me into serious internal conflict. I am very aware, however, of how difficult it was for me to see something so very obvious, that I was trying to dominate Marina, that I felt somehow privileged to do this, when actually I should have simply supported Marina in her aim to feel safe in a movement she wished to support, in whatever way she and her group thought best. Afterall, they are the one's who feel unsafe, not me. That's troubling, that I was so basically blinded.
I'm glad though, that there are others like Marina out there, who are prepared to take a stand against idiots like me, to challenge us, in whatever way they see fit, to change the way we approach the whole issue of gender privilege in society. Thank God, there are such people!
So, finally, I would just like to say how grateful I am to all the people involved in this change in my perception, the men and women who wrote the blogs and comments that came together to bring about this altered perception. I plan to keep a watchful eye on myself in this regard in the future. And also, within the Occupy movement and beyond, I plan to simply support women, and other marginalised groups, to express themselves in whatever way they see fit, and, basically, to avoid sticking my oar in where it doesn't belong.
I am deeply sorry.
One major challenge, to be detailed in this blog entry, is realising how women are treated in society, and by me, and how men, like me, often feel as if we have a right to tell women what to do. Take my humiliating, and humbling, experience below.
Who am I to....
Last week, I stumbled upon a blog by Marina S on "Portable Safe Spaces and Occupying the Occupation" via the #OccupyBristol Twitter Feed.
The blog clearly outlined a problem: women were not feeling safe on the Occupy Bristol site. It clearly proposed one possible solution: women could form a closed group on the site, a group that would aim to maintain a certain number of women in that group at all times. In this way, the blog concluded, no single woman would be made to feel vulnerable. Simple, right?
Wrong. Along comes an arrogant, meddling, white privileged male ass (me) with a response that went something like:
I think this idea is great, but it sounds like the group is women-only. I'm a feminist man, and I would like to offer my support. (I have since deleted this post as I was too ashamed to leave it up.)
Essentially, though I hadn't seen it yet, I had said:
But, what about me? What about men?
For now, I simply felt as if I was offering constructive criticism, as no doubt other men also felt who made their own suggestions, only to find themselves met with cutting replies, replies that were venomous, scathing, enraged.
I was left shocked, stunned, baffled by these responses, not just from Marina, but others too. My replies detail this disbelief and are still available to see. They chronicle my struggle to see Marina's point of view, my struggle to understand why Marina was so upset. On top of my confusion, clouding my mind, was my ego, deeply bruised, revolting against the public scolding. I spent a sleepless night and a tense day turning over in my head what I had said, and how Marina had responded. Surely, I hadn't said anything that bad. Surely...
Thankfully, I brooded. I took a look around. I came across another blog by Marina, her SlutWalk Bristol speech, which, apart from being passionately and brilliantly written, refers to the harsh fact that there are 94,000 rapes in the UK every year. Accounting for repeat victimisation, that means 55,000 women are raped - every year. The worst thing about this figure is that a third of people will believe that the woman was somehow to blame for being raped. Surely the only person to blame for the rape is the rapist, right? Apparently not, according to popular opinion, because if she flirted she's partly to blame, or if she was too drunk, she's partly to blame. In any case, here was a reality I did not have to think about every day of my life. I was not vulnerable to being one of these 55,000 rape victims. Why? Because I am a man.
So, now I had some numbers, some facts. Uncomfortable facts. I still struggled to understand what was wrong with my comments, though. Why had I provoked Marina to reply so aggressively? What, if anything, had I done wrong? I was tempted to dismiss her as an angry feminist, but no, that was too easy. I wanted to understand.
I continued looking around, clicking through links on Marina's pages, and so on. Then, my next deeply educational moment came along, via an article I found, unapologetically titled, 'Dick Privilage'. Here, the author, Forty Shades of Grey, addresses Richard Dawkins, who attempted to downplay, indeed deny, the reality of Rebecca Watson's discomfort when she was propositioned at 4am in an empty elevator by some guy, after having given a talk on how uncomfortable it made her feel to be sexualised. Forty Shade of Grey speaks to Richard, thus:
You don’t get obscenities shouted at you in public because you dare to be out of the house while in possession of a vagina. You don’t get men refusing to move out of your way at work so you have to rub up against them to get somewhere you need to be immediately. You don’t get forced to not wear a top you like because it’s a bit low cut and the last time you did a customer literally stared at your tits for two hours solid. You don’t get patronised because your reproductive organs are on the inside. You don’t get seen as a being that is only good for sex one minute and reviled the next if you dare to reveal yourself as a sexual being. You don’t get forced into choosing between a career and a family. You don’t get told that you won’t succeed because of those pockets of fat and muscle on your chest. You don’t get treated as a member of a minority group when you in fact, form the majority of the population. You don’t get accused of being a hysterical, over-emotional, boring bitch when you don’t want to fuck someone and you don’t want to be propositioned for sex at 4 in the morning in a hotel after you JUST SPOKE about how uncomfortable this made you feel. You also, and I can not make this clear enough, do NOT FUCKING GET to tell people who this stuff actually happens to on a daily basis how to feel.
Something clicked: it was the 'you don't get to tell her how to feel'. Marina's reply to me came to mind:
John: oh my god. Why did you have to barge into this conversation and demand to be catered to? I am apoplectic with rage at you right now, for smearing your privilege like a turd all over my monitor. It will be up to the women in the group to decide what your role is, it is NOT for you to make a case. Argh. (emphasis added)
I saw, vaguely, that I was trying to have a say about something I had no personal experience of and had no real right to direct. More than that, there was something about control here. Forty Shades of Grey has quite clearly painted a picture of a woman not in control of her environment, her culture. She had no control over being seen as less-than within her society. Then, along comes me, white privileged male, who's never experienced such marginalisation, misogyny, and abuse, convinced I should have a say in what Marina's group do or do not do in order for them to feel safe.
A rather simple idea was slowly dawning on me: Women, just because they're women, feel less safe than men, because men are convinced that they have a right to dominate women, just because they are men.
And what was I doing? I was trying to tell Marina what to do. Oh, Christ, I thought, I think I get it. I was mirroring the problem, not the solution. My values, which I had assumed beneficent and relatively progressive and egalitarian, began to reveal themselves as nothing other than "privileged". Even though I wasn't telling Marina what to do because I thought she was less than, I was still trying to tell her what to do within a culture of male privilege which has for centuries dominated her as a woman, just because she is a woman. Her rage, I realised, was perfectly understandable.
Finally, it was the following analogy, contained in the comments of Forty Shades of Grey's blog:
An analogy: For arguments sake, take it as a given that only 0.01% of the handguns in the world are loaded.
You're in a lift, with a man. He pulls out a pistol, cocks it, and aims it at your head.
Do you decide it's statistically okay, and that no harm will come to you, or do you worry, at least a little bit, that you might be about to have your head blown off.
The pistol is analogous to a cheesy pick-up line from a stranger in a cramped place, with no exits.
An unloaded pistol is a line from a man who doesn't intend to take things further if a woman says no.
A loaded pistol is a line from a man who intends rape.
Question: How do you tell the difference and if you can't, why would the perceived possible-threat from the unloaded-gun man be non-zero?
This ended, for me, some decades long tensions I had been carrying, often emerging in angry deabtes with my feminist partner, about how I always felt insulted and outraged when women talked about men as rapists. But I'm a man, I'd say, angrily. And I'm not a rapist. I don't want to be seen as a rapist! But, now I was thinking: And? What's your point, John? Some men are rapists, clearly. And quite a few actually, if 55,000 women get raped every year. Women don't know which man is the rapist, and which man is not. It's not for you, John, like Dawkins, to go about demanding women not feel scared of you, or uncomfortable, because you're not a rapist. They do feel scared, uncomfortable, unsafe, because some men are rapists.
It was all falling into place.
I was seeing differently, but I was also behaving differently: Walking across the road, I noticed a women walking along the path I was about to join. It was dark. Previously, I wouldn't have thought anything about it, and, as she was a little ahead of me, I would have ended up walking behind her, only to feel annoyed by the thought 'maybe she feels scared by me walking behind her' because I don't want to be seen as a rapist. This time, however, I simply accepted that she might feel uncomfortable if I ended up walking behind her on a dark street with not many people around. So, I sped up a bit and joined the path walking in front of her. End of problem. Simple. Afterall, which is more important, my desire to not be seen as a potential rapist, or her fear that I might be just that, a rapist?
Naturally, I hesitated a while before openly apologising to Marina on her blog - blasted pride! - but I found myself arguing against other men who were making comments similar to my original remark: telling Marina how she and her group should be on the Occupy Bristol site.
All of this, of course, was a very humbling experience. I still feel rather uncomfortable about it. As a counsellor, Health Care Assistant and Support Worker, I had hoped to be more aware and sensitive to the experiences of the marginalised, having worked with the sexually, emotionally and physically abused, people seen as having "mental health issues," and people with learning difficulties. All these people are to some extent excluded or marginalised by society. I had even called myself a feminist! But, I had discovered just how much my privilege had blinded me to their experience.
I feel very grateful for Marina's replies to my initial stupidity, in that their venom catapulted me into serious internal conflict. I am very aware, however, of how difficult it was for me to see something so very obvious, that I was trying to dominate Marina, that I felt somehow privileged to do this, when actually I should have simply supported Marina in her aim to feel safe in a movement she wished to support, in whatever way she and her group thought best. Afterall, they are the one's who feel unsafe, not me. That's troubling, that I was so basically blinded.
I'm glad though, that there are others like Marina out there, who are prepared to take a stand against idiots like me, to challenge us, in whatever way they see fit, to change the way we approach the whole issue of gender privilege in society. Thank God, there are such people!
So, finally, I would just like to say how grateful I am to all the people involved in this change in my perception, the men and women who wrote the blogs and comments that came together to bring about this altered perception. I plan to keep a watchful eye on myself in this regard in the future. And also, within the Occupy movement and beyond, I plan to simply support women, and other marginalised groups, to express themselves in whatever way they see fit, and, basically, to avoid sticking my oar in where it doesn't belong.
I am deeply sorry.
Saturday, October 22, 2011
Words: Powerful Propaganda Tool or Vehicle of Truth?
Observe the media, politicians, and big business and we see that this is the age of propaganda and non-truth, but are we then to join the spinners and weavers of words, or are we with greater vigour determined to counter-balance such myth-makers with honesty and truth?
A genuine question!
In an age when the powerful say what is useful, leveraging, and self-serving, ought we to join in the game and use words in an equally pragmatic way, as useful, leveraging, and self-serving, abandoning truth as we do so?
Indeed, are words anything more than propaganda tools? Is "truth" in itself merely a useful term, a leveraging and self-serving use of words? I don't genuinely believe it is. I believe there is truth. There is truth in the sense of authenticity, being true to oneself, and also, there is truth in the sense of words representing empirical data.
Yet, despite this, despite my belief in truth, this doesn't answer the question, alternatively asked: Am I obliged to be truthful, when I'm surrounded by the powerful who use non-truth as propaganda, words as merely useful, leveraging, and self-serving?
Of course, if I were to "join" them, the only difference between us then would be our motive, our agenda. My words would be "useful," "leveraging," and "self-serving" in the sense that they seek to achieve my own agenda of weakening the capitalist economic model. Our values and ends would differentiate us, though our means would be the same.
Yet, despite this, despite my belief in truth, this doesn't answer the question, alternatively asked: Am I obliged to be truthful, when I'm surrounded by the powerful who use non-truth as propaganda, words as merely useful, leveraging, and self-serving?
Of course, if I were to "join" them, the only difference between us then would be our motive, our agenda. My words would be "useful," "leveraging," and "self-serving" in the sense that they seek to achieve my own agenda of weakening the capitalist economic model. Our values and ends would differentiate us, though our means would be the same.
Finally, I am aware that being authentic, being true to oneself, does not demand that I adhere to speaking only what is empirically true. I might become duplicitous. I might, for example, on the one hand be true to myself, by answering my heart-felt call for justice in the face of the current economic depravity of unregulated capitalism, whereas on the other, I might abandon empirical truth by, for example, propagating false or misleading statistics that would serve me in my aim to create a more equitable society. I would be fighting smokescreens with smokescreens, while all the time remaining mirror-clear about my true values and soul-feelings.
Let me give you an example. Here's a metaphor I came across today. It describes the current psychological situation of most middleclass people in Western capitalist society: "When the cake gets smaller, we're reduced to fighting over crumbs. Time to take over the bakery..."
Now, this metaphor serves my purpose, in that it proposes "taking over" the way in which capitalism is run. It also accurately captures the reality of what Nietzchse desribed as "resentiment". It's concise. It's smart. It's powerful. However, there is a catch. The metaphor is incomplete, and ignores certain empirical realities. For example, even if we did take over the bakery, we still wouldn't control how much the raw materials cost, the flour, the oil. In a world of limited resources and an increasing population, prices are destined to rise, and so a cake for the same price is bound to get smaller. So, our metaphor collapses.
Now, here's the rub: I can choose to use this metaphor duplicitously, by ignoring this detail, because it would nevertheless help me achieve my agenda of more firmly regulating capitalism; even if to do so I know I am not being fully "honest".
Let me give you an example. Here's a metaphor I came across today. It describes the current psychological situation of most middleclass people in Western capitalist society: "When the cake gets smaller, we're reduced to fighting over crumbs. Time to take over the bakery..."
Now, this metaphor serves my purpose, in that it proposes "taking over" the way in which capitalism is run. It also accurately captures the reality of what Nietzchse desribed as "resentiment". It's concise. It's smart. It's powerful. However, there is a catch. The metaphor is incomplete, and ignores certain empirical realities. For example, even if we did take over the bakery, we still wouldn't control how much the raw materials cost, the flour, the oil. In a world of limited resources and an increasing population, prices are destined to rise, and so a cake for the same price is bound to get smaller. So, our metaphor collapses.
Now, here's the rub: I can choose to use this metaphor duplicitously, by ignoring this detail, because it would nevertheless help me achieve my agenda of more firmly regulating capitalism; even if to do so I know I am not being fully "honest".
For sure, feminist, anarchist, and activist theories often bring this to the table, giving a kind of nodding smirk towards duplicity as poltical power.
So, the question is: Is it OK to be duplicitous, to deliberately spread and disseminate half- or non-truths in order to achieve one's authentic agenda?
I do not know...
I do not know...
Wednesday, September 7, 2011
A Letter to my MP, Stephen Williams (Lib Dem)
Dear Stephen,
I would just like to say that I am very disappointed that you voted "yes" on the NHS bill: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmtoday/cmdebate/c_22.htm. Indeed, I was under the impression that you were going to vote against it. I had previously forwarded you two petitions from 38Degrees on the dangers of this bill being passed, and you indicated in your reply to them that you'd be voting against it, that you were "against the changes to the NHS". (http://www.38degrees.org.uk/page/content/NHS-legal-MPs-replies). You have seemingly, at the last minute, changed your mind.
It now seems to me and others that the Liberal Democrats would rather stay in power at any cost than stand by your own party's principles and leave the coalition; I, amonst many others, have lost faith in the Liberal Democrats as a viable option to the conservatives.
Next election I will be voting Labour, and in the mean time I will be doing everything in my power to protest, demonstrate and uphold my civic duty to stand by the vulnerable and less well off in society. This is unlike the coalition party, who seems intent on helping the rich get richer (eg. recent executive wage rises are 63%) while the less well off get poorer (eg. average worker wage rises are up only 27%, though this hardly matches the rising cost of living) (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-14781254).
Next election I will be voting Labour, and in the mean time I will be doing everything in my power to protest, demonstrate and uphold my civic duty to stand by the vulnerable and less well off in society. This is unlike the coalition party, who seems intent on helping the rich get richer (eg. recent executive wage rises are 63%) while the less well off get poorer (eg. average worker wage rises are up only 27%, though this hardly matches the rising cost of living) (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-14781254).
That this "recession" is being used to rob the lower middle classes of money and services, including youth centres, and transfer that money to the rich is frankly disgusting. That the tax payer is paying for the banking industry's greed, with no hope of ever being repaid, is disgusting. That the government is 'pausing' its attempt to regulate the banking industry at the banking industry's request is distrubing. That you do not agree with the EU Robinhood tax, is baffling. That you have made an agreement with Switzerland over Tax Havens that does not remove account secrecy and essentially legitimates tax avoidance is astounding (compare this with India's deal: http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/industry-and-economy/banking/article2397144.ece?%20homepage=true. For more see: http://johnmcguirk.blogspot.com/2011/08/tax-havens-and-swiss-deal.html
In short, the government seems to have no metal in standing up to the unethical and self-serving nature of big business. So, perhaps it is time for the people to do so for themselves, through protests and civil disobedience, of the kind we saw last year, with occupations of shops who seemingly avoided their taxes.
I'm no expert, Stephen, but all of this boggles the mind. This is capitalism gone way out of control. I'm sure you feel you know more about the inner workings of politics, where compromise is important. But to voters, this just looks like daylight robbery.
And I see no other option but to protest this government's and your decision as aggressively as I legally can.
The liberal democrats have lost their heart in my view. You all would do better standing down and sharing power with Labour as a strong voice of disapproval of the current state of affairs.
Yours etc...
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Tax Havens and the Swiss Deal
I highly recommend Richard Murphy's recent blogs on the coalition's attempt to make a deal with the Swiss government, which essentially means big businesses who try to evade paying their taxes by using tax havens abroad will not pay the 20, 40 & 50% tax that we individuals have to, but rather, closer to a meagre 3.75% tax.
Now, it's up to you whether you think this is fair, that an individual citizen has to pay 20 - 40% tax on their income while a big business has only to pay 3.75% tax.
Have a read of Richard's blog and see what you think. I admit the situation is a complex one. Richard sees this as the coalition's attempt to scupper the EU's attempt to completely do away with tax havens by demanding an end to the secrecy that is the basis of Swiss banking. Others see this as the UK's attempt to at least get some tax back (a mere 3.75%!), arguing that the EU's deal was never going to happen. Richard is adamant that one way or the other this is legitimising criminality. In that, he is totally correct. He is also correct in arguing that this is one major way the rich filter money from the poor to the rich, as such "breaks" are not available to the typical worker/individual income earner. (Swiss banks usually have a £100,000 deposit limit etc.).
So, personally, this is a reason to get angry, and do something.
On a final note, I find Richard often has what feels like a rather rude manner, but I essentially agree with his fundamental point: Tax Evasion is a crime, and the government's latest attempt to cut a deal with the Swiss effectively legitimates criminality. If looters get 6 months for robbing 6 bottles of water, how come businesses get away with robbing millions of pounds worth of taxes from us, UK citizens, every year? It doesn't make sense. We need to have a level playing field, and soon! So, just ignore his rudeness, or what he calls his "robust" responses. His heart's in the right place. Bless.
Here's a place to get started: Let’s not get personal – this is a matter of right or wrong by Richard Murphy
Now, it's up to you whether you think this is fair, that an individual citizen has to pay 20 - 40% tax on their income while a big business has only to pay 3.75% tax.
Have a read of Richard's blog and see what you think. I admit the situation is a complex one. Richard sees this as the coalition's attempt to scupper the EU's attempt to completely do away with tax havens by demanding an end to the secrecy that is the basis of Swiss banking. Others see this as the UK's attempt to at least get some tax back (a mere 3.75%!), arguing that the EU's deal was never going to happen. Richard is adamant that one way or the other this is legitimising criminality. In that, he is totally correct. He is also correct in arguing that this is one major way the rich filter money from the poor to the rich, as such "breaks" are not available to the typical worker/individual income earner. (Swiss banks usually have a £100,000 deposit limit etc.).
So, personally, this is a reason to get angry, and do something.
On a final note, I find Richard often has what feels like a rather rude manner, but I essentially agree with his fundamental point: Tax Evasion is a crime, and the government's latest attempt to cut a deal with the Swiss effectively legitimates criminality. If looters get 6 months for robbing 6 bottles of water, how come businesses get away with robbing millions of pounds worth of taxes from us, UK citizens, every year? It doesn't make sense. We need to have a level playing field, and soon! So, just ignore his rudeness, or what he calls his "robust" responses. His heart's in the right place. Bless.
Here's a place to get started: Let’s not get personal – this is a matter of right or wrong by Richard Murphy
And if you are in any doubt about options available to the uk governemnt see the following link:
This link shows how India was able to sign an alternative deal to the uk-swiss treaty.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)